| Year | Name (Event) |
|---|---|
| 1964 | Al Miyamoto (PH) |
| 1970 | Steve Rochell (SR) |
| 1972 | Howard Bessen (SR) Steve Hug (AA, PH, PB, HB) |
| 1973 | Steve Hug (AA, V, PB, HB) Ted Marcy (PH) |
| 1974 | Howard Bessen (SR) Steve Hug (AA, PB, HB) Ted Marcy (PH) |
| 1975 | Ted Marcy (PH) |
| 1976 | Ted Marcy (PH) |
| 1984 | Jon Louis (SR) |
| 1985 | Jon Louis (AA, PB) |
| 1986 | Randy Besosa (HB) Jon Louis (AA, HB) |
| 1988 | Randy Besosa (AA, PB) Mike Matzek (SR) Conrad Voorsanger (PB) |
| 1989 | Tim Ryan (AA, PB) Scott Schaeffer (PB) Conrad Voorsanger (AA, PB) |
| 1990 | Jair Lynch (HB) Conrad Voorsanger (PB) Charles Loop (HB) |
| 1991 | Jair Lynch (AA, PB, HB) |
| 1992 | Jair Lynch *** (AA, FX, PH, PB, HB) Tim Ryan (AA, PH, SR) |
| 1993 | Jair Lynch (FX, PB) Josh Stein (FX) Jing Wei Liang (PH) |
| 1994 | Ian Bachrach (FX) Mark Booth (AA, FX, PH) Josh Stein (AA, PH, V) Keith Wiley (V) |
| 1995 | Ian Bachrach (V) Jamie Ellis (PB) Andrew Manson (SR) Josh Stein (AA, FX, PH, SR) Keith Wiley (V) |
| 1996 | Ian Bachrach (FX, V, HB) Jamie Ellis (PB) Jeremy Herman (PH) Clarence Miao (V) Keith Wiley (AA) |
| 1997 | Scott Finkelstein (PH) |
| 1999 | Jason Katsampes (AA, PH, PB) |
| 2001 | Marshall Erwin (SR) Dan Gill (V) |
| 2002 | David Durante (HB) Marshall Erwin (SR) Dan Gill (V) |
| 2003 | Marshall Erwin (SR) Dan Gill (AA, V) |
| 2004 | Peter Derman (SR) Dan Gill *** (AA, FX, PH, V, HB) |
| 2006 | Dylan Carney (V, HB) Peter Derman (SR) Nate Downs (HB) Sho Nakamori (AA, FX) Alex Schorsch (SR) David Sender (AA, SR, V, PB) |
| 2007 | Dylan Carney (HB) Peter Derman (SR) Chris Harper (PH) Alex Schorsch (SR) David Sender (AA, SR, V) |
| 2008 | Alex Buscaglia (HB) Dylan Carney (HB) Josh Dixon (FX, V, HB) Bryant Hadden (SR) Sho Nakamori (AA, PH, PB) Kyle Oi (PH) David Sender (AA, SR, V) Greg Ter-Zakhariants (FX, PH) |
| 2009 | Alex Buscaglia (HB) Tim Gentry (V, SR) Bryant Hadden (SR) Ryan Lieberman (PB) Sho Nakamori (PB, HB, FX) Nicholas Noone (SR, PB) Kyle Oi (SR) |
| 2010 | Alex Buscaglia (FX, HB) Josh Dixon (V, PB, HB) Tim Gentry (SR, V) Ryan Lieberman (PB) John Martin (PH) Nicholas Noone (PB, SR) Eddie Penev (V, FX) Abhinav Ramani (HB) |
| 2011 | Alex Buscaglia (HB, PB) Josh Dixon (FX, AA) Cameron Foreman (PB) Tim Gentry (SR, V, FX) Ryan Lieberman (AA) Eddie Penev (FX) Chris Turner (PH) |
| 2012 | Eddie Penev (AA, FX, V) Sean Senters (FX) Cameron Foreman (PB) Paul Hichwa (FX) |
| 2013 | Cameron Foreman (HB) Brian Knott (PB) John Martin (PH) Eddie Penev (AA, FX, V) Sean Senters (FX, V) Dennis Zaremski (PB) |
| 2014 | Brian Knott (PB) Michael Levy (FX) Akash Modi (AA, PH, PB) Sean Senters (FX, V) Dennis Zaremski (SR) |
| 2015 | Brian Knott (PH, PB) Akash Modi ** / *** (AA, FX, PH, PB, HB) Robert Neff (HB) Taylor Seaton (V) Sean Senters (V) |
| 2016 | Brian Knott (PB) Akash Modi ** (AA, FX, PB, HB) Taylor Seaton (HB) Dennis Zaremski (SR, PB) |
| 2017 | Akash Modi ** / *** (AA, PH, V, PB, HB) Andrew Misiolek (PH) Robert Neff (AA, PB, HB) |
| 2018 | Grant Breckenridge (HB) Robert Neff (AA, HB) Blake Sun (PB) |
| 2019 | Jacob Barrus (PB) Andrew Bitner (SR) Grant Breckenridge (HB, AA) Ian Gunther (SR) David Jessen (HB) Brody Malone ** / *** (PB, HB, FX, SR, AA) Bailey Perez (FX) Bryan Perla (FX, VT) Blake Sun (PB) |
| 2020 | Brandon Briones (VT, AA) Trevor DiGerolamo (SR) Ian Gunther (PH, SR, PB, AA) Connor Lewis (VT) Riley Loos (SR, AA) Brody Malone ** (VT, PB, AA) Zach Martin (VT) Curran Phillips (VT, PB) |
| 2021 | Brandon Briones (VT, AA) Ian Gunther (SR, PH, PB) Riley Loos (SR, FX, HB) Brody Malone ** (HB, SR, FX, AA) Zach Martin (VT) Curran Phillips (VT) Blake Sun (PB) |
| 2022 * | Mark Berlaga (SR) Taylor Burkhart (PH) Ian Gunther (SR, PB) Thomas Lee (SR) Riley Loos (FX, SR) Brody Malone ** / *** (FX, PH, SR, HB, AA) Zach Martin (VT) Bryan Perla (FX) Curran Phillips (VT, PB) Blake Sun (PH) Colt Walker (PB) Khoi Young (PH, VT) |
| 2023 | Brandon Briones (SR) Taylor Burkhart (VT, HB) J.R. Chou (PH, HB) Asher Hong (SR, VT, AA) Nicolas Kuebler (FX, SR) Brandon Nguyen (PB) Khoi Young (VT) |
* Denotes team's highest number of All-Americans in one season (20 awards)
** Brody Malone and Akash Modi hold career record of 17 All-American awards
*** Jair Lynch ('92), Dan Gill ('04), Akash Modi ('15 & '17) and Brody Malone ('19 & '22) are tied for most All-America honors at a single NCAA Championships (5)